2024 Crime Recap | The Year of the Gasp
CASE STUDY
Abuse & neglect of children in Georgia foster care system.
Senate Judiciary Committee Subcommittee on Human Rights and the Law Majority Staff Report
April 9. 2024
March
Madeline Soto
Florida
Just barely a teenager, Madeline Soto celebrated her 13th birthday with family and friends before suddenly vanishing the following morning. Her face filled headlines in the hours after her disappearance was reported to law enforcement.
Questions and suspicion surrounded the alleged pleas from Soto’s mother and her mother’s boyfriend, Stephan Sterns. The appeal for her safe return was met with more public scrutiny with every hour that passed. law enforcement was well aware of the glaring issues with the missing persons report and statements from family and people who knew Soto.
By the beginning of March, Soto was found by investigators. Her body was abandoned in a wooded area not far from the road. By the time Soto was found, Sterns was already in custody after illegal content was found on his phone of Soto. Content that Sterns attempted to delete after Soto was reported missing.
Sterns is now awaiting trial for the mass quantity of illegal content found on his phone and the murder of Madeline Soto. Her disappearance has highlighted the importance of consistently being observant of your child and who is around them.
April
Suzanne Morphew
Colorado
In 2020, Colorado law enforcement released a missing persons report for Suzanne Morphew after she was found to have seemingly vanished from her home in Salida. Morphew’s husband quickly became the primary suspect as all the evidence appeared to point to him.
While her husband awaited trial, politics and incompetence surrounded the investigation. The lead prosecutor was at the center of an unfolding scandal of her own making. Morphew’s case was only one of thousands that were affected by the incompetence.
The charges against Morphew’s husband were eventually dropped, for now. Meanwhile, during an unrelated search in September of 2023, the body of Suzanne Morphew was discovered and her autopsy results were released in April of 2024.
Certain details of the autopsy pointed to the logical theory of the case, toxicology showed that a mixture of chemicals were present in her body. The same chemicals could have been used in the tranquilizer evidence that was found at Morphew’s home and later detailed in the arrest of her husband. No charges have been filed since her remains were found in 2023.
May
Adam Montgomery
New Hampshire
On May 9, Adam Montgomery appeared in court to be sentenced for murdering his 5-year-old daughter, Harmony Montgomery. At the time, Adam Montgomery had already faced a trial for illegally possessing firearms and was already beginning his 32-75 year sentence in prison.
Montgomery refused to attend the trial and, through his lawyer, claimed he did not harm his daughter but he did admit to disposing of her body. The prosecutor gave Adam an opportunity at sentencing to reveal where he left his daughter in exchange for a lowered sentence, Adam declined the offer. Harmony was missing for years before law enforcement began investigating her disappearance.
Adam Montgomery’s wife, Kayla Montgomery, testified against him at trial. Kayla painting a horrific scene for locals who attend many of the businesses that Adam is accused of hiding Harmony’s body at, including well known and frequented establishments he worked and lived in.
The judge sentenced him to 45 years to life in prison. No one has seen Harmony since 2019 and searches for her are ongoing in New Hampshire.
Sofia Koval
Florida
Lauderdale Lakes teen, Sofia Koval, has lived the majority of her life in limbo. She eventually moved from Ukraine to the United States to live with her father and grandmother.
In May, Koval brutally murdered her grandmother in a disturbing incident that appeared to have started over her grandmother scratching Koval on the head. She did not appear to be remorseful according to documents, but was visibly upset at court hearings. The documents also appear to claim that Sofia was having severe mental health complications, but it was unclear if that was a major factor in the crime.
Ultimately, Koval’s charges were reduced to manslaughter and she was sentenced to serve three years in juvenile custody. When her sentence ends, Koval could be held over for additional supervision or deported back to Ukraine. It appears she will continue to live in limbo until she learns her ultimate fate after the juvenile sentence is complete.
Chad Daybell
Idaho
Chad Daybell, an author from Utah, became well known in the national media in 2019 when his portal of lies transformed into a portal of accountability. Daybell’s life around this time was surrounded with questions. His actions did not make sense to those who knew him, a move from Utah to Idaho seemed to ignite more concern about what he might be up to.
The author was not well known prior to 2019, aside from his presence in the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-Day Saints. Daybell and his wife at the time, Tammy Daybell, ran a publishing company with a focus on books that could be sold at their church book store. Some of the publications explored conspiracy theories, extreme religious ideas, and a nauseating take on life and relationships.
After moving his family to Idaho, Daybell’s wife, Tammy, mysteriously died in October of 2019, shortly after an incident that appear to be an attempted shooting targeted at Tammy. By November 5th Daybell married a woman who showed interest in his publications and extreme ideations, Lori Vallow. The two became acquainted before Tammy’s death.
Lori Vallow was available to marry Daybell after her husband was shot by Vallow’s brother in an alleged self defense incident that is now headed to trial as a murder case. Vallow also had two children living with her, Tylee and JJ. On December 20th, 2019 Rexburg Police Department announced that Vallow’s youngest two children were missing.
In 2020, Vallow was arrest first after refusing to prove her children were safe and months later Daybell was arrested when a new search of his home revealed human remains, later identified as Tylee and JJ.
Following their arrests, an avalanche of information revealed a delusional plan without any real direction. Secret meetings in the LDS temple, fraudulent calls to obtain life insurance, and throughout it all, it seems as though they were both manipulating each other.
Most logical individuals could see through the facade that Daybell and Vallow were trying to portray, in reality the two seemed to have an ultimate need to be seen as special. In may, a jury convicted Daybell of murdering his wife at the time, Tammy, and Vallow’s two children, Tylee and JJ. The jury also sentenced him to death.
September
Sean Combs
New York
Sean Combs is known known by a variety of names, from Puff Daddy to Diddy, but his attempts to rebrand over the years did not stop the rumors of criminal behavior and sexual deviance.
On September 17, Combs found himself in a similar situation as his 1997 album title, “No Way Out.” Federal prosecutors charged Combs with sex trafficking and racketeering.
Combs appeared to be surprised that his multiple attempts to be released on bond failed. Prosecutors claimed in court that he is a flight risk, has allegedly coordinated witness intimidation, and attempts to manipulate the public and possible jury pool. Overall, the prosecution alleged everything that rumors have alleged about Combs for decades.
The list of horrific lawsuits and possible co-conspirators continues to unfold on a weekly basis. He is accused of sexual assault with victims ranging from children to adults. Ironically, Combs has not yet been charged with the crimes he has been rumored to have committed over the years. The investigation is still ongoing.
October
Alex Murdaugh
South Carolina
Even in 2024, Alex Murdaugh continues to make headlines with ongoing civil suits, criminal appeals, and co-conspirator updates. Thankfully the flow of shirtless photos and inside information about jailhouse gambling and beef sticks has stopped, for now.
In October, the incident that revealed what was behind Murdaugh’s mask finally reached a conclusion. Many of his crimes were discovered after the fatal boat crash in 2019. His son, Paul Murdaugh, was driving the boat at the time, after an evening of drinking. Mallory Beach was on the boat that night and lost her life when Paul crashed into a Beaufort County bridge.
The civil settlement was finally reached, marking an end to what seemed to be the tipping point to expose Murdaugh’s crimes.
H
Suzanne Clark Simpson
Texas
After attending a party at The Argyle with her husband, Brad Simpson, the couple split up and Suzanne headed to a local store, H-E-B. Minutes after leaving the store, Suzanne’s cell phone service was disconnected by her husband and they were later seen fighting at their home late that evening.
What exactly transpired after that is currently unknown, but the evidence all points in one direction, Brad Simpson. The search for Suzanne’s remains is ongoing while Brad is in custody awaiting trial and refusing to cooperate with investigators.
November
Susan Smith
South Carolina
A 2024 curveball that many did not see coming, the first parole hearing for Susan Smith. For those who do not recall, Smith was convicted of murdering her sons, Michael and Alex, and then told police that a black man hijacked her with her two sons in the car.
Smith has allegedly never shown remorse to anyone, including the father of Michael and Alex. Her parole hearing was shocking to many people who believed that life in prison would mean that Smith would spend the rest of her life in prison. State by state, sentencing and parole varies based on state law.
Smith appeared with a lawyer present to mostly speak for her, aside from the theatrical performance she attempted to display for the board. She was denied parole and will likely be eligible again in two years.
George Gascón
California
For man,y George Gascón is a political figure. He began his role as the Los Angeles County District Attorney in 2020, promising progressive changes in criminal justice reform. Gascón was supported by controversial figures and advocacy groups that claim they seek to reform the criminal justice system.
In the end, Gascón’s policies and radical changes appeared to be harmful to Los Angeles County residents.
December
Brian Thompson
New York
2024 ended with a bang, quite literally. On December 4th, the morning news displayed security footage of a dark figure on a Manhattan street shooting a man in the back in what appeared to be a targeted hit. The poorly lit footage then shows the murderer leaving the scene.
Later in the day, reports continued about the shooting and the ongoing effort to track the shooter. The victim was revealed to be Brian Thompson, a CEO for United Healthcare. Thompson was in town for an investors meeting.
For days, the NYPD tracked the suspect and released any information that might help the public identify him. The shooter was noticed at a Pennsylvania McDonald’s were he was arrested and held until the NYPD could transfer him to New York to face murder charges,
The days following his arrest were, and still are, filled with support for the shooter who’s manifesto read more like a self absorbed confession. A defense fund was started for the alleged shooter and many have claimed support in the name of healthcare fraud and manipulation. Although, in his notes that have been released, the alleged shooter claimed that the CEO, “checked all the boxes.” Appearing as if the target was not solely healthcare related.
The shooter is now awaiting trial in custody in New York. He faces a state and a federal trial.
Lori Vallow Daybell
Idaho
Lori Daybell, Lori Vallow, Lori Ryan Vallow Daybell, whatever you call her.. Lori kicked off the Christmas gift giving season with her motion to go pro se and represent herself after having her mormon garments handed to her in the last trial. In a true gift to defense attorney’s across the land, Lori refernced her vast knowledge of the law library when citing her reasons for choosing to represent herself. Lori Vallow and Chad Daybell became known to the public through videos that showed them rumaging around Hawaii and avoiding questions about where two of Lori’s children were and if they were safe. This is a common situation when a parent is complicit in their child’s disappearance. But this was much different than your normal avoidance of accountability. Lori and
Chad Daybell was sentenced to the death penalty this year, back in June, after a jury found him guilty of conspiring with Lori to take the lives of Tammy Daybell, Tylee Ryan and JJ Vallow.
Rex Heuermann
New York
In 2022, investigators in New York organized a team to address a decades-long evil presence in their community. For far too long the community was haunted by the fact that a serial killer was among them, but who? And where does he even live? No one knew, but rumors chaotically named a variety of individuals including local sex offenders and law enforcement officers.
Investigators soon found themselves tailing an architect in Manhattan, in an attempt to collect his DNA. The results of that DNA test opened pandora’s box of horrors that would create more questions than it answered.
The DNA, collected from a discarded piece of pizza crust, was the piece of the puzzle that investigators were looking for, the suspect was officially identified as Rex Heuermann. The Manhattan architect was arrested and has now been charged with murdering Melissa Barthelemy, Megan Waterman, Amber Costello, Maureen Brainard-Barnes, Sandra Costilla, Jessica Taylor, and Valerie Mack.
The investigation into additional victims is ongoing as Heuermann awaits trial for his current charges of murdering seven women.
Samuel Bateman
On December 10, Samuel Bateman joined the ranks of convicted Fundamental Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-Day Saints (FLDS) members. In 2011, the leader of the FLDS church was convicted of child sex crimes. The organization believes in the practice of having multiple wives and secluding themselves from society as much as possible. The organization was once under the leadership of now convicted Warren Jeffs. After Jeffs was sent to prison, he demanded very restrictive rules for the remaining members. The restrictions are believed to have been a motivating factor for Samuel Bateman to create his own group of followers. Bateman entered a guilty plea for conspiracy to commit transportation of a minor for criminal sexual activity and conspiracy to commit kidnapping.
The arrests for crimes against children within the FLDS has caused chaos for everyone in the organization and continues to torment those who have left. The arrests ignited more criminal activity in an effort to keep the children of the organization under the control of Warren Jeffs belief system.
No one simply leaves the FLDS unscathed, especially if you have children or siblings. Following Bateman’s arrest, more children are still being located and reunited with their family. Even still, the effort by FLDS leaders to kidnap or coerce children back to the organization is still ongoing.
Justice for Abby Williams & Libby German
Indiana
Abby Williams and Libby German’s faces have circulated in international media since 2017, often appearing alongside a blurry photo of a man on a bridge, that man became known as, “Bridge Guy.”
The public has heard their story through media, podcasts, and personal accounts. The haunting details of how they were murdered still linger in the minds of parents and small communities. No one wants to think that two innocent girls cannot just go and enjoy the outdoors without encountering evil, but that is exactly what happened to Abby and Libby in the small community of Delphi.
The crime turned residents against each other, ignited rumors that still linger no matter how many times they are proven false, and changed the way Delphi residents lived on a daily basis. With each new passing year after their murder, it seemed a new face was added to the potential suspect pool. None of the potential suspects fit the profile, nor did they match up to the evidence.
In 2022, a volunteer discovered an overlooked piece of information that was obtained in the early phases of the investigation. A man who came forward to let law enforcement know he was at the bridge that day, as residents had been asked to come forward if they were there. After reviewing the information and conducting an investigation into the person of interest, law enforcement could not rule him out.
By October of 2022, law enforcement officially arrested the person of interest turned suspect, Richard Allen. A Delphi resident who worked at the local CVS. The exact profile that law enforcement and the majority of logical sleuths had assumed the suspect would reflect. A local resident, laying low, someone who knew the area well and may have even had an interest in the area of the crime scene. Richard Allen fit the description, and the evidence.
After confessing over sixty times and attempting to appear insane while in custody, Richard Allen finally went to trial with the legal team who appeared willing to win at any cost, including the truth. Allen’s legal team was briefly thrown off the case for lying to a judge and for not properly ensuring that discovery evidence was remaining confidential. Multiple crime scene photos of the victims were released to the public after being leaked from the defense attorney’s office. Attorney Andrew Baldwin still deflects from this incident, acting as if it is not an issue that deserves his time and attention.
After a long year of leaks to podcasters, manipulation of facts, and complete lies, Richard Allen appeared for trial. Those who support his defense continued to claim the judge presiding over the case was corrupt and working with the state. Ignoring the fact that the same decision the judge made, were systematically made in other cases across the country. Allen’s supporters have resorted to insulting the victims and anyone who does not agree that Allen is innocent. Their claims are not backed by facts or any evidence that can be displayed in a courtroom.
The jury heard the evidence and thoroughly examined it during deliberations. Richard Allen was then found guilty of murdering Abby and Libby in 2017. A crime he spent months confessing to, meanwhile fighting in court. Whether or not it was Allen’s choice to go to trial is still unknown. His wife attended trial and appeared to support his innocence in court. Allen did not have support from family in court aside from his wife, who also appeared to doubt his innocence when Allen was questioned by police.
Allen was sentenced to130 years in prison. His supporters will likely continue to claim his innocence and recite his appeals. Most well-known convicted felons, especially murderers, do continue to have support after their conviction. Unfortunately, Allen’s supporters fail to stick to the evidence and instead resort to insulting anyone who does not agree with their narrative. The justice system and law enforcement is under public scrutiny and that can create an easy landscape for attorney’s to manipulate the system and label it as due process. This tactic has become more common in recent years.
OPERATIONS
FEBRUARY 20, 2024
Amelia Spires is convicted of cruelty to children and aggravated sexual battery
JANUARY 3, 2024
Fulton County Jail records show her father, Rodney McWeay, faces fourteen criminal charges, including murder and cruelty to children.
DECEMBER 22. 2023
Nearly a dozen former state social workers have filed a federal lawsuit against their former employer — the Georgia Division of Family and Children Services
NOVEMBER 2, 2023
Hoteling numbers are down because children have been placed in group homes, private homes, and in some cases, overnight stays at DFCS offices
MAY 13, 2023
Sandy Springs Police made contact with a mother now charged with murder in her 1-year-old’s death a day before the child died
APRIL 28, 2023
Roy Payne of Calhoun is charged with three counts of felony child abuse, three counts of felony child molestation and one count of felony sodomy
DECEMBER 2, 2021
“Something has got to be done, because the next step a child could be killed,” said Former DFCS Caseworker.
AUGUST 20, 2019
The Reveal investigators have uncovered records showing more than 40 percent of caseworkers who had disciplinary issues in the last four years at DFCS
JULY 30, 2019
Christina Queen agreed to sell her baby to William and Rebecca McClain in exchange for a 2006 Jeep Grand Cherokee